The Possible Folly of Zubiri

Zubiri’s folly is very much possible.

From ABS-CBN News:

Record-high palm oil prices due to voracious global demand for the oil used for food and now increasingly as a biofuel have left many ordinary Indonesians without their usual culinary fare.

Palm oil-derived cooking oil is a staple in the Indonesian pantry. It is used to fry many of the spicy dishes that are part of the local cuisine.

But the high price of oil has forced millions of poor Indonesians to eat their food boiled instead of fried.

“I only have fried tempe when I have money, but mostly I don’t,” said Nurhayati, a mother of five, referring to a traditional dish made from fermented soya beans.

“So my family just eats rice … and soy sauce,” she added as she scrubbed pots in a house where she works as a maid earning 300,000 rupiah ($33) a month.

In a country where about half the 220 million population live on less than $2 a day, the rising price of cooking oil is a national talking point sensitive enough to make politicians break into a sweat.

Long queues of people waiting to buy cooking oil — empty plastic containers in hand — could recently be seen in markets, a scene reminiscent of the financial crisis in the late 1990s that brought down the rule of strongman former President Suharto.

Two years ahead of the next election, President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono has come under pressure for his record on tackling the impact of rising commodity prices on local staples after promising to slash poverty.

“It’s a warning for the government,” said Ganjar Pranowo, an opposition parliamentarian.

PRICES SURGE BY A THIRD
Palm oil prices have been driven up by rising demand for biofuel in Europe and strong demand from food sectors in countries such as fast-growing India.

As one of the world’s largest palm oil producers, Indonesia stands to gain from the price hike, but the rise has also pushed up local cooking oil prices by about a third, making such oil unaffordable for millions of ordinary Indonesians.

As well as hurting the poor, rising cooking oil prices are worrying economic policy planners due to the impact on inflation.

Raw food prices including cooking oil rose by just over 10 percent in June from a year ago, the sharpest increase in a basket of goods and services making up the consumer price index.

Malaysian crude palm oil futures have surged about 80 percent since the start of 2006, pushing up Indonesia prices.

Saman, a 55-year-old fried snack vendor in central Jakarta, says his profits have almost halved to 25,000 rupiah a day since cooking oil prices surged.

“I use at least 8 kg (17.6 lb) of cooking oil a day. I have been thinking of quitting since the profit is so low, but I have done this for 30 years. I have no other choice,” said Saman, whose son has dropped out of school due to lack of money for school fees.

The government had urged producers to supply crude palm oil to local refiners at lower prices so that non-branded cooking oil — widely consumed by low-to-middle income brackets — can be sold more cheaply.

But to little avail.

“Even if we tried to push down the prices, markets tend to cling to a price level set by international markets,” said Derom Bangun, executive chairman of the Indonesian Palm Oil Producers Association.

WORLD’S TOP PALM OIL PRODUCER
Indonesia is expected to produce 17.4 million tonnes of palm oil this year, overtaking Malaysia as the world’s top producer.

In mid-June, the government cranked up the export tax for crude palm oil to 6.5 percent from 1.5 percent in a bid to ensure supply to local markets. The tax appears to have had some impact, but cooking oil prices are still higher than in the past.

Analysts suggest the government should let prices follow global palm oil prices, but focus more on helping low-income bracket families with subsidised cooking oil.

“The government could buy cooking oil at market prices and sell to poor groups at lower prices,” said Rina Oktaviani, an economist at the Bogor Institute of Agriculture in West Java.

“If cooking oil is considered a strategic commodity then the government must be responsible to make up for shortages in supplies,” she said.

10 thoughts on “The Possible Folly of Zubiri

  1. Palm oil! That’s what Malaysians have been trying to cultivate in our own backyard.

    The Malaysians started on a land buying spree in the South (Mindanao) as early as 1997-1998 with former Sen Joey Lina “lawyering” for some of them.

    I suspect this is one of the reasons why they want to stay on top of the situation in the so-called govt peace talks with the MILF.

  2. Zubiri’s short-sighted law will encourage a shift from food crops to biofuel crops.

    Eventually, a choice has to be made: Who do you feed – yourself or your SUV?

  3. The shortage of wheat has led to skyrocketing prices of bread. The shortage is due to the crop conversion of wheat-producing countries. They now plant corn. Zubiri’s family will earn big-time with his bio-fuels law. How convenient isn’t it?

  4. Killed 2 birds with 1 stone: Boom … global warming & population explosion to slow down.

    Read that Al with HOH is the fuel of the future. Clean emission.

    Of course, there’s nothing wrong with walking. Clean air.

  5. Hi, Mam Anna, I cannot say if what is the interests of the Malaysians on the peace talks. Unless they are meddlesome neighbors…

    Hi, Sir MB, Zubiri can feed himself and his SUV, thank you very much. That leaves us losers.

    Hi, Schumey, everyone has the right to earn his bread (sarcasm).

    Hi, Arthur, that’s right, but not at the cost of people getting hungry. There’s no use for clean air if people are dying because of hunger.

  6. Actually, biofuels are not that clean. Their value is geopolitical, in that we become less dependent on the fossil fuel suppliers. I think it’s good economics to sell higher value crops so i don’t mind biofuels in that respect. My suggestion is to either redistribute the income from biofuels to the farmers or redistribute the land itself.

  7. Sir Arbet,

    This was what Chiz was talking about during the campaign (kailangan isingit si Chiz:)) He was not excited with the alternative fuel because he said that it might trigger food shortage. Apparently, it’s already happening in the country. Tataas daw ang tinapay kasi mahal na ang trigo.

    Ano kaya ipapakain ni Zubiri sa atin?

    Jowana

  8. Eat half a cup of grain each meal and a bowl of vegetables & friuts. Have 6 oz. of meat, if you must, a day. Eat fish. Don’t fry your food; boil them. Better still eat them raw. Use less salt. Throw away the fish sauce. Eat often, but in small portions. Eat to live; not live to eat. Walk 45 min. a day. Drink moderately everyday.

    Visit your doctors; visit your dentist.

    Warning: you need cholesterol for a better sex drive.

Comments are closed.